Join the debate

Search

Post your resume

Back

Print

Should London be more like Dubai?

22 July 2008

OK, the City will never have beaches, weeks of uninterrupted sunshine or temperatures in excess of 40 degrees, but it could probably muster up lenient tax regulations for overseas bankers. Is this what's needed to make sure London is still a global financial centre in 10 years' time?

According to the Telegraph, some people think so.

The Treasury's new Financial Services Global Competitiveness Group has engaged McKinsey & Co. to produce a report looking at what can be done to see off the threat from nascent financial centres.

Dubai appears to be considered the most threatening. In the words of the article, it has gone from being “bleak” and having “Arab-style buildings in one area” and “not much in the way of entertainment”, to (in our words) a fully fledged expat pleasure palace.

The Telegraph quotes an “insider”, who says the McKinsey report should result in “radical change”: “One idea is to build a London Financial District with special property and tax regulations, along the lines of Dubai. Perhaps better tax rules should be introduced for foreign companies and workers.”

Do you agree? Should overseas bankers pay lower taxes than born and bred British ones? And is Dubai really that much of a threat anyway? Your opinions please...

Comments (26)

The last thing London needs to do now is to cut the tax rate for overseas bankers. This government has racked up the highest budget deficit for decades

View all comments

Bookmark

  • Digg.com
  • Del.icio.us
  • Stumbleupon.com
  • Reddit.com
  • Yahoo.com

Comments (26)

  • Total rubbish that if you're unemployable you'll have to leave the UK! There are those who have become very wealthy by making the move. Having an office job in London isn't the be-all and end-all of life. If you are a failure at home then it's highly unlikely you'll be a success in a foreign land.

    There are some 50,000 Brits and Americans in Saudi alone. Losers all? Don't think so. When they return home, they will have some serious money.

    Trefor 04 Aug 2008

    RECOMMEND Recommended 0 times | Alert Moderator

  • Dubai, as many have mentioned, is indeed populated by losers who have, in most cases, fled bad situations back home, or are otherwise unemployable in their country of orgin (and judging by their ever increasing numbers applies mainly to Brits - FILTH comes to mind).  Hats off to though to the PR firm that has marketed Dubai, a great example of style over substance.  Banks that have rushed to staff offices here will most likely find that there are not nearly the number of deals to be had as the headlines might indicate.  They will also find that the (obligatory) Arabic speaking "door opener" that they paid gazillions to for "access" was in fact little more than a fraud (and will quietly release said huckster after 2 yr contract rolls off)...look for many to be packing their bags and getting back on the plane by 2010/11...London/NY have nothing to worry about, Dubai is flavour of the month

    A Siddiqui 03 Aug 2008

    RECOMMEND Recommended 0 times | Alert Moderator

  • Just look at dubai. overpopulated with people from subcontinent like india and other arab nations. how can it be like london? dubai has massive human rights abuses ? how can it be like london? legal contracts have no standing? how can it be like london? the goverment is interfering with the supply of real estate to create artificial price hike? how can it be like london? UK is a democracy. dubai is not?  Dubai does not offer passports, so how is it like London?

    London rules 30 Jul 2008

    RECOMMEND Recommended 0 times | Alert Moderator

  • As mentioned, it helps to make friends with locals. God forbid that some of the superior London types to mingle with those swarthy characters, eh?

    John 29 Jul 2008

    RECOMMEND Recommended 0 times | Alert Moderator

  • London was evolved. Dubai is Genetically Modified.

    ANANDSHARMA 27 Jul 2008

    RECOMMEND Recommended 0 times | Alert Moderator

  • I’ve lived in Dubai for 20 years and have lived in London for 7 years. London will always be London, everyone knows all the pros and cons. Dubai however is an ever-changing garish/beautiful illusion. It is what you make of it, a paradise for the true entrepreneur, where you can get things done. This isn't the case for overnighters, those who aren't willing to commit to the long haul. Furthermore, the negative comments here come from expats who most likely have no Emirati friends nor will ever experience the elusive but wonderful culture behind Dubai.

    Besides, when you look at all the recent acquisitions (e.g. LSE, Chrysler Building) Dubai and Qatar will own most of London and NY within a decade. So maybe London will in fact became Dubai, by ownership.

    CC 25 Jul 2008

    RECOMMEND Recommended 0 times | Alert Moderator

  • A mate of mine spent three years in Saudi and hated every minute of it! He did manage to pay off his mortgage and is now settled in Canada. None of that would've been possible had he not 'roughed' it in Saudi.

    Everyone wants the money/status but not what it takes to get there! Easy life isn't what it seems...

    Bob 25 Jul 2008

    RECOMMEND Recommended 0 times | Alert Moderator

  • All depends. If you like to live in a half-completed disneyland city and being brainwashed to think that Dubai is the center of the earth and the eight wonder of the world, then, yes, you will like it.
    If on the other end, you like a real city, some form of public transportation, temperatures below 45C, and skilled labour, then you won't like it.

    gfd 25 Jul 2008

    RECOMMEND Recommended 0 times | Alert Moderator

  • No one arrives thinking they can make it. Try turning up in such a place (Dubai) without a job placement! You’re either sent there or have contacts there.

    Attending an office job that has an accompanying ‘good’ salary isn’t a sign of ‘making it’ in London. This is the snobbery of someone who’s been riding the boom of recent years. Money puts people into a false sense of security and believing they are invincible while everyone who's not doing the same is inferior.

    I couldn’t get a job in London and learnt my trading skills in Asia. I now run my own trading operation. I had no time for the pool or mall – too busy building a business. So easy being an office worker on a salary…

    Not bad for a failure who couldn’t make it in London! If you feel there are opportunities in other countries then go for it. Don’t rely on a job which you can lose at a moments notice.

    John 25 Jul 2008

    RECOMMEND Recommended 0 times | Alert Moderator

  • Yes, off course. Tax benefits is the only reason we overseas bankers are here. We need compensation for the abysmal living conditions. I know no fellow overseas banker/person who would stick around for another day wouldn't there be a monetary upside to being here. And most leave as soon as their financial objective of being here is met. Well unless they decide to bail out before, as many do when they can't stand it any longer. But the money is good, so yes please, more tax benefits is a splendid idea!

    Money Penny 23 Jul 2008

    RECOMMEND Recommended 0 times | Alert Moderator

Add your comment

* Mandatory

You have 1200 characters left

Enter the code shown here or sign in / register to skip this step. (What is this?)

Post comment

Jobs

Col3
Col4
Col5
Col6
bottom

Site Information

eFinancialCareers is a Dice Holdings, Inc. company. Dice Holdings, Inc. is a publicly traded company listed on the New York Stock Exchange (Ticker: DHX)